WebMD Blogs
Community

Healthy Children

From cold and flu to ear infections, Dr. Steven Parker shares information and advice on how to keep your children happy and healthy all year round.

background

WebMD Health News

Wednesday, January 18, 2006

Your kids: Accept them as they are
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Dr. P in P-Town

Over the holidays, my wife and I made our annual trek to Provincetown, Massachusetts. As some of you might know, "P-Town" is a very old whaling town, perched on the easternmost tip of Cape Cod. It also probably has the highest per capita gay population on the planet, which lends it a unique, festive atmosphere.

We were sitting at the bar of our favorite restaurant, awaiting friends to join us for dinner. The young man behind the ancient wooden countertop told us it was his first weekend there as a bartender, so please bear with him.

Now, we are at the stage of life where it's hard to tell how old a young person is. Early 20s? Late 20s? Early 30s? They all look the same (read: real young) to us. We asked him if he had just turned old enough to bartend.

"No," he replied. "I've actually been working in restaurants here in P-Town for 10 years and was a bartender elsewhere for 3 years."

Working 10 years already? Looking at his young face, the math did not compute. We asked him how that could be possible.

He sighed. "When I was 14 years old, living in a small town in New Hampshire, I came out to my parents. I told them that I knew I was gay - always had known, really - and I wanted to share it with them. Long story short: they told me that it was unacceptable, against God's will and everything they believe in. I should pray hard and change my ways. If that didn't happen, I simply couldn't stay with them."

"That week," he continued, "I packed my bags and took a bus to Provincetown, where I heard they would take in guys like me. When I arrived at the P-Town bus station, there was a large sign advising homeless youths to call a number to receive shelter and support. I guess I wasn't the first kid to be in this position."

"I called the number and they put me up with Bill, who had volunteered to take in stray cats like me. As it turned out, Bill became my foster father and I have been living with him for the past 10 years. He had two demands: I had to finish high school and I had to work to earn my keep."

"And so I have. Early on, I decided that the restaurant business was for me. Some day I hope to have my own restaurant here in P-Town. In the meantime, here I am."

We were stunned, horrified, saddened. What parents would banish their 14 year old son from their home? And, for what? A sexual orientation he was born with and had as much ability to change as his being lefthanded? And he seemed such a nice, sweet kid.

Our bartender, on the other hand, was cheerful as he poured our wine. Maybe he had told the story so often it had lost its emotional weight. Or could he really have come to terms with his heartbreaking past?

We asked him if he had any contact with his parents. "Funny you should ask. Last week I went home for the first time since I was banished. It was great seeing my brother and two sisters. Of course, my parents didn't really talk to me; they don't want to know about how I'm living my life and certainly not about my boyfriend. But, to their credit, at least they let me in the door."

I couldn't resist, "Aren't you just so angry at your parents. I have to say, I don't hear it in your voice, but it was such an unfair and cruel thing for your parents to have done to you."

"Sure, on some level. But I've also come to forgive them, at least partly. I've decided that they have about as much ability to change who and what they are as I do to change who and what I am. We'll probably never have a great relationship - maybe not one at all to speak of - but hating them for how they have treated me just doesn't help. I like who I am now, what I have become, and my life. Maybe they deserve at least a little credit for that."

Again, we were stunned, but this time at the level of maturity and wisdom of this young man - a poster boy for resilience in the face of adversity.

We raised our glasses of wine. "God bless P-Town."

"Amen!" he agreed, as he moved on to other customers.

--------------------------------x-----------------------------

As some of you know, I have long counseled that it is your job as a parent to discover - not invent - your child. But what if the human you discover is antithetical to your hopes, your dreams, your strongly held convictions of how a child should be?

I'm convinced that a lot of short and long term parent-child grief emanates from parents who can not accept who and what their child is: not smart enough... not good-looking...too active...too shy...too intense...too laid back...developmental challenges...


Go ahead and add your own pet peeve to the list. Most parents have at least a few. Nature often trumps nurture, and many parents become frustrated and angry at their inability to change unappreciated characteristics of their child.

I'm going to defer my usual "Dr. P's comments" and brilliant suggestions for another blog, and let you ponder this common dilemma: how can you as a parent best handle it when your child has certain traits that just don't fit into your image of the perfect child? When the child you love isn't always the child you like?


Related Topics: Making Peace With Your Past, Sexual Orientation Not Debatable


Technorati Tags: , , ,

Posted by: Dr. Parker at 1/18/2006 10:05:00 PM

13 Comments:

Blogger Lynsey said...

I have a question I hope you can answer. My 5 year old son seems to have an excessive amount of saliva. When he talks, he is constantly slurping it up. Like 3-4 times per sentence. Is this normal??

1/19/2006 03:44:00 PM  
Blogger WebMD Blog Admin said...

Hi Lynsey --

I'd try posting this question on Dr. Parker's message board. There are lots of parents there who might help you and Dr. P does try to answer as many questions as he possibly can.

1/19/2006 04:19:00 PM  
Anonymous Elizabeth Reid said...

I don't know. It's hard. It's sometimes the hardest when the trait you're seeing is something you detest in yourself, something you *know* has caused you trouble and grief in your life... and you want to take your kid and try to scare that trait right out of them to make their life easier than your own was.

But they can't just up and stop being the way they are any more than you as the adult ever could or can now, so it's a dumb impulse.

1/24/2006 10:20:00 AM  
Blogger DRJ said...

Great topic.

It seems to me this can be a matter of degree. Kicking your kid out of the house because he is gay is one extreme; Trying to reform some unpleasant traits (as Elizabeth Reid allludes to) is quite another.

I can't imagine ousting my 14-year-old from the house for any reason. Even if the child is a danger to others or in danger, the parents still have the obligation to provide for the child's food, shelter, and safety. At a minimum, they should provide for the child's living arrangements rather than evict him. And from a Christian perspective, you can hate the act without hating the person. Thus, there is no justification for what happened to the young bartender you met, and I'm hopeful that there is more to this story than he told you. Either way, however, he was just a child and it's a shame.

For the more mundane problem of having a child you love but don't like - join the club! There are often times I love my spouse and children but don't like what they do. Like Elizabeth, all too often those disagreeable traits come from me and I know it, which makes it even worse. When I see my spouse's disagreeable traits in one of our children, it can be frustrating but it also makes me chuckle with amazement at how THAT got there. It is seeing my faults repeated that's particularly unpleasant.

Of course, some parents are correct to love but not like their child. I know a dangerous child - he likes to play with fire and hurt animals and other children - and I think it would be entirely normal for those parents to strongly dislike their child for such behavior. Sadly, though, they are in denial.

1/24/2006 12:12:00 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It's really sickening to see pediatricians using their medical authority to tart up their banal PC ideologies. If children are by one's sincere judgment morally repugnant, one MUST cast them off. It is one's duty to Gd, a duty that trumps all others.

If your son insisted upon being a sadistic pedophile, would you allow him to live with you? For some Christians/Jews, pedophilia and homosexuality are equally evil.

You may disagree--fine. But that's not the issue

1/24/2006 03:15:00 PM  
Blogger Wacky Hermit said...

When my first child was born, I gazed at her in horror one day as I realized that I was never going to get it right as a parent; that no matter what I did, I would be irretrievably saddling her with emotional baggage of one sort or another. It took me a while, but I kind of resigned myself to it. Once I knew I was going to screw up and accepted that, I was easier on myself and was able to congratulate myself for the times I got it right.

My biggest dilemmas now come from trying to keep my kids from saddling each other with baggage. My daughter is a perfectionist who gets great joy from hyperachievement and following the rules. My oldest son is very creative and benefits from a more relaxed hand, with constant and gradual discipline. So my daughter sees my son being "let off the hook" for things she would never have allowed herself to get away with as he learns one small thing at a time, and my son is jealous of my daughter's prodigious accomplishments.

Somehow I've managed to have two children who each think they are the red-headed stepchild in the family, even though I love them both and try my best to raise each of them in the style that is least damaging to them. I try to show each of them how to accept the other's differences, but some days it just doesn't seem like it's working. Maybe by the time they're adults, they'll get it.

1/24/2006 10:42:00 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"how can you as a parent best handle it when your child has certain traits that just don't fit into your image of the perfect child? When the child you love isn't always the child you like?"

I simply remember that I am--in certain ways--surely a disappointment to my parents. Who nonetheless love me dearly, and make me know it, and always have. So I try to emulate them. Hopefully some day my children will show me the same respect, since I'm positive I"ll not be their image of a perfect father.

Love, for a parent, often requires PRETENDING to like your kids, in a really good way. Because if your kids feel you dislike them for who they are, you are failing as a parent. Note that this does not preclude you from discimplining, restricting, or otherwise "parenting" your children. Nor does it preclude you from hating them for a day, it happens to everyone when they temporarily turn into hellions. But if, on a daily bases, you don't like your child--and if that isn't changing--you should not be their parent.

1/25/2006 02:18:00 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I find it to be extremely upsetting when I hear stories about parents casting their children from their home because they don't like or agree with what they are doing. As parents, it is our job, a job we took on when we made the choice to become a parent, to provide a loving home where a child can feel secure in being who they are. Yes there are times when I look at my son and see certain traits I wish weren't there but as I think about the things my childe does that I don't like I realize they are more of a reflection of the things I didn't like about myself and an indication that my son will experience some of the troubles these traits brought me. As a parent it's only natural for me to want to protect my child in any way possible but at the same time I need to let him live and be who he is. As Khalil Gibrahn wrote: "your children are from you but not of you". We need to allow them to live their own journey in this lifetime in the most positive way possible. I know I don't get everything right and as hard as I may try and want to, I know, generally speaking, I go to bed at night doing the best I can. If a parent denies their child a secure, loving home they are letting their own issues, demons, supercede the needs of their child and their responsibility as a parent. It's not easy being a parent but what in life is ever always easy. Becoming a mom, for me, gives me a mirror for me to look into everyday and a deeper understanding of who I am.

1/28/2006 11:57:00 AM  
Blogger hrtbrk101 said...

That was a sad story. Being a parent was my goal in life. My first born was truly a miracle and I loved him so much. So how could I kick him out at 18? He's now 20 and still doing the same thing - nothing. I thought I was enabling him to be lazy and unmotivated. As soon as puberty kicked in, my son had changed. He became lazy, grumpy, verbally abusive, disrespectful, and destructive. We tried counseling (three years), he was treated for depression and bi-polar disorder but was never properly evaluated. He would laugh at me if I cried during the counseling sessions. They tagged him as bi-polar because he biological father was supposedly bi-polar. He made it through school because I cared and so did his teachers. The verbal abuse became really offensive and his tantrums were unbelievable and scary. By 18 he was off his meds -- they hadn't done anything anyway. He was dabbling in alcohol and pot, refused to keep his room clean,and couldn't hold a job. He completely destroyed his room, kicked down the door to our home, among breaking numerous other things. I feared for my daughters safety as well as for my own. Since my husband is a big man, I thought he would be fine. He has been out of the house for two years and it's been a virtual roller coaster. He lives with friends but cannot find employment. His only desire is to play his guitar and earn money that way. I've given him money and groceries. I've supported his 6 failed attempts at getting his license. He has a vehicle that he physically "beat up" during one of his tantrums. He doesn't see that he's done anything wrong. He had an opportunity to get into the Navy recently. The only thing we had to do is clear his name on a court matter. For six weeks, I provided him with room & board money only to find out it wasn't being used for that. Everyone jumped through hoops for this kid and the judge agreed to drop the release conditions if he joined the Navy. Well - he changed his mind. Even the recruiter was really annoyed after all we had done. I feel guilty sometimes and heartbroken other times. I wonder what happened to my sweet boy and how this 20 year old became such an agressive, disrespectful human being. You can suffer heartbreak over the loss of a love, but nothing greater than how your child can break your heart. The truth is I cannot accept this person the way he is. He believes that we owe him a living. I believe that I now have a right to some peace before the stress kills me.

4/20/2006 03:13:00 PM  
Blogger Steve, CEO PassportMD said...

I am a physician, parent and have a medical service company. I believe in what you are doing. Whether you speak for or against these issues, the dialogue itself is the answer and is what will keep all sides "healthy". I write a blog called Keep Seniors Healthy, http://keepseniorshealthy.blogspot.com/ and in it, I cover such topics as "Are we medicating our children too much?", it is worth the read and has some very informative statistics. I also created a site where people can for FREE take control of and create their own health records, that can be found at http://www.PassportMD.com it also would be a helpful site for parents and children needing to stay "healthy".

11/09/2006 06:21:00 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing this story...
This was truly a sad but compelling story with an interesting topic. I feel that this is pure child abuse and parents that cast their children out are most definitely unfit parents and they are the ones that should be “removed from office”. They should pay the price not the child, who is just trying to come to terms with who he/she is. It is fortunate that this story ended on a positive note and not a statistic that we all too often hear about. This young man was very fortunate to have a father figure come into his life.

Lately my son has shown signs of depression about school and we try to give him back positive reinforcements by rationalizing his feelings by talking things over. He is worried he is bi-polar.

Sometimes I believe that many times parents try to re-live their childhood that they may or may not missed out on, in which can be equaling damaging. I've seen this in athletics especially. High expectations can be good but they can also go overboard.

B.T.W- I love P-town!

3/07/2007 02:40:00 PM  
Anonymous Chaunce said...

Its amazing that people can be so ignorant to believe that there is a choice here. Absolutely no homophobe can say that its always a choice when they never have to experience it. What happens ALWAYS happens for a reason. If someone is homosexual, then it was intended to be that way. Anything that happens is NOT against gods will. God could easily end all homosexuals if he/she/it truly hated them. For all the people who think homosexuality is wrong, think for yourself rather than being told what to repeat by a group of fascist, under evolved, people of subnormal intelligence what to repeat.

3/14/2007 01:17:00 AM  
Anonymous James Carpenter said...

The young bartender's story is reenacted every day around this country. Did you know that homeless youth are around 20% gay and lesbian, while we gays are only about 3% of the population overall? I don't know that much about the God of Christianity, but surely he would find that a troubling statistic, if he reads the paper.

Those who blithely counsel to "hate the sin but love the sinner" have likely never been on the receiving end of that kind of hate-love. In practice, it takes such forms as always having to slip into the conversation, "of course, I don't agree with your 'lifestyle', but...", and the like. Yeah, we figured that one out. You tell us all the time. Kinda hard to feel the love.

If it involves hate, then it isn't love. Period.

I honestly don't know what your solution is as Christian parents, when you're convinced that the way we are is so wrong. Perhaps the solution is to pay a little more attention to the Beatitudes than to the Ten Commandments. Perhaps it's to be a little more careful about casting that first stone, and the second, and the third. Perhaps it's to try, just for a little while, to walk in your kids' shoes before condemning them.

Apparently, the God of Christianity is somewhat interested in sex, but VERY interested in justice, mercy, forbearance. It's hard to see those priorities in the perspective and actions of many christians.

Unlike "anonymous", I sign my name.

4/10/2007 10:31:00 PM  

Post a Comment

background