WebMD Blogs
Icon

TV Checkup

We're obsessed with television. As employees of America's number one health site, we often find ourselves questioning the medicine behind our favorite medical TV shows. Do the docs on ER and House really know their stuff? And just how common is that rare disease on last night's Grey's Anatomy?

background

WebMD Health News

Wednesday, January 10, 2007

House Deleting Memories
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Memories, pressed between the pages of a patient's mind.

Last night House centered on making and erasing memories, and how those memories can be a shock to someone's health. Electroconvulsive therapy was the star of the show.

Without totally recapping the episode, a patient was finally diagnosed with a spinal meningioma, a tumor that can grow on the dura, one of the membrane that cover the spinal cord and brain.

The tumor was causing the patient to believe a woman, with whom he was secretly in love, was engaged to be married to his brother. The stress of this unrequited love was so great it induced a string of heart attacks that had to be controlled. Oh, and the brain tumor was troubling as well.

So was his lady friend engaged to his brother? No... and House called it a false memory, a delusional side effect the spinal tumor. And yet, how do you stop someone from believing something that's so vividly real for them that it causes a heart attack at the thought?

An off-label use of ECT, apparently. ECT uses electric currents, administered with electrodes placed on the scalp, to send a current through a brain for about 8 seconds. Side effects can include short and long-term memory loss.

By shocking his brain, House erased the patient's memories of the lady and the love he bore. And his brother. And why he was in the hospital. And probably other things we can't know because the patient forgot them, too.

Dr. Melissa Conrad Stoppler, one of our medical experts here at WebMD, says this use of ECT is a bit creative on House's part, because there is no way to know if the right memories would be gone...if any.

"Can ECT affect memory? Absolutely. But can you use ECT to 'obliterate' specific memories? No. ECT can affect memory in different ways. Some people undergoing ECT have a partial loss of memory of events that occurred before treatment began, but most commonly; this involves memory of the weeks or months prior to treatment.

Some people do have problems with recollection of more distant past events, but it is not possible to predict how a given individual will react and what type (if any) of memory deficits will occur as a result of the procedure. The memory problems usually improve within a few weeks to months after the procedure, with return of the majority of the 'lost' memories."


So for House, the cure for a broken heart, delusional or not, is shock therapy. I wonder what he'd prescribe for road rage?

Related Topics: Broken Heart Syndrome

Posted by: Kathy_WebMD at 1/10/2007 04:14:00 PM

4 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I love the show but this one was way out there. Too dramatic.

1/12/2007 12:28 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yeah, I agree--but all of the shows are unrealistic. I work part time in a teaching hospital, and there's nothing realistic about the show, lol. But I love it anyway, love the storylines, love House.

I personally thought the more interesting part of this episode was his rehab and supposed conversion to "nice guy", lol. Again, all unrealistic, but a nice twist. Great show.

1/12/2007 1:36 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

i think that yes, the medical part of this episode was a bit out there, but not the most unrealistic.( I mean the epidose that was really out there was the one where he woke the guy from the coma. )
in this epidsoe the side story seemed to be a bit mroe important, which was different than it normally is in the show. Either way House is an amzing and addicting show.
I cannot believe they are making us wait 3 weeks for the next new one. That is what is unbelievable

1/15/2007 3:43 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

House is one of the best doctor shows on tv in my opinion. It may not all be by the book but then isn't that what tv is all about? Losing yourself for just a little while. Forgetting all your problems for just a few moments. House is the kind of guy you have a love/hate feeling for. You can't help but love him even though you sometimes would really like to put him in his place kinda like the cop did!

1/15/2007 5:50 PM  

Post a Comment

background