WebMD Blogs
Icon

TV Checkup

We're obsessed with television. As employees of America's number one health site, we often find ourselves questioning the medicine behind our favorite medical TV shows. Do the docs on ER and House really know their stuff? And just how common is that rare disease on last night's Grey's Anatomy?

background

WebMD Health News

Friday, March 28, 2008

The Biggest Loser--Couples: This One Takes the Cake!
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

There are only two shows left in the season and it's hard to know where the producers can go from here. They say, "When you hit bottom, there's no place to go but up." We certainly hope that's true, although there appears to be a special place reality television goes, and it's below bottom.

It was hard to watch the latest installment of Biggest Loser--Couples, and not wonder what aliens from a far off galaxy landing on earth might think. For argument's sake they land on "campus" only to find a man carrying around a slice of chocolate cake as a pet, while his compatriots tease him and hide his cake in the laundry to teach him to better protect his pet. And then these same people run up and down stairs, gathering junk food and placing it on tables, occasionally taking a bite. The point here was to put as many calories on someone else's table so they could lose the challenge.

The aliens would likely think they had landed on a planet where intelligence was not valued, but a high premium was placed on trans-fat. They would not be entirely wrong. But in watching the episode we felt more like the aliens.

A solid hour, we're not kidding, was spent on Dan's relationship with a slice of cake. He carried it with him everywhere. There were shots of the cake in the gym. Shots of the cake in the kitchen. It was downright bizarre. And idiotic.

And as if that were not idiotic enough, the second hour was centered around a challenge that was not only insulting and inane, but also infuriating. Infuriating because despite the fact that there are no real teams left, Bob's blue team remains strong and intact, and viciously determined to wipe out "the girls." They work out together, strategize together, and still raise their unified voice in "PRIDE" whenever they get the chance. And they approach each task with an eye toward how they can eliminate one of the remaining two women and strengthen their hold on the game. And because there are four of them and only two women, the women barely stand a chance.

The two remaining women, Kelly and Ali, have not exactly been united. Kelly is the sole remaining member of Jillian's black team, and Ali came back in that strange twist a few weeks ago, and still wears her pink team shirt with pride. This week, disgusted and demoralized by the men's behavior, the women decided to unite; Jillian gave them pep talk after pep talk and they rallied, determined not to be eliminated. In the end, the united men could not save Dan from elimination, after he lost only a pound. The women, in fact, were first and second at the weigh-in.

There were the teary goodbyes, now customary for the men. Weeping, vowing eternal love, pledging PRIDE despite the fall. Ugh. We're so sick of the men conniving and conspiring to gang up on the women, macho, mean, and ruthless, and then collapsing into quivering, sniveling babies at the end.

We have been saying for awhile now that this show has lost focus; this week proved once again that weight loss, exercise, healthy eating, changes in lifestyle--all take a backseat to pet cakes and boys versus girls sexist mentality.

Two episodes left. Four more hours. 240 minutes. But who's counting.

(c) NBC Universal.

Related Topics:

Technorati Tags: , , , , ,

Posted by: Nancy Davis, Safety4Kids at 3/28/2008 10:08:00 AM

Wednesday, March 12, 2008

The Biggest Loser--Couples: From Fierce to Farce
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

It's time NBC renamed this show "The Biggest Kvetcher". Seriously, if we have to continue to watch grown men and women crying over their interpersonal issues, we're going to start crying ourselves.

There is absolutely nothing of substance to talk about. Last night this show hit bottom. For no apparent reason, all of the previously eliminated players reappeared for a "special" weigh-in. The eliminated man and woman with the highest percentage of weight loss would come back on the show. This pissed off almost all of the remaining contestants, who thought they had long ago disposed of their fellow teammates and had reached the status of "final six".

Side note: the players who had been eliminated did not look very good. Other than the two who won, not much change to report.

Mark and Ali were reunited with the group. Mark, crying as always, over his brotherly love, easily assimilated back into Bob's team. One, two, three, PRIDE! It was another story entirely for Ali. She and her mom, Bette Sue, you will recall, had serious issues, but Ali was a fierce competitor and a friend to many of the men on the blue team. She chose to wear her original pink clothing, rather than adopt Jillian's signature black. Ali was keeping her options open. She was more interested in wearing pink as an homage to her mother than giving that up and joining the women in black.

And who could blame her?

Those women in black? Simpering, annoying, emotional wrecks. Crying, over-eating, barely moving on the treadmill...what's going on? Why isn't Jillian kicking their butts into high gear? And what about Jillian? She used to be fierce. She seems on the edge herself. She lost her cool completely at the final weigh in, swearing and glowering at Alison Sweeney, the usually sweet host. Alison seemed unprepared and inarticulate, but the whole scene just confirmed the soap opera status to which this show has sunk. At least Alison is back in her milieu.

As if we hadn't suffered enough, we did not get the satisfaction of anyone being eliminated! Ooh...that's for next week...we're on the edge of our seats.

So here's what was really lost this week on The Biggest Loser:

  • storyline (this was weak to begin with; now it's gone completely)

  • focus on weight loss (remember when that's what this show was about?)

  • direction (no one is in charge)

  • patience (even the trainers are at the end of their ropes)

  • sense of humor (ours, not theirs)


And oh yes...actual weight loss? Not so much. Not figuring very prominently anymore in this show. It's true that a couple of the men have lost over 100 pounds each. That's remarkable. And we applaud their commitment and results. But that's a tiny part of the show. More time is spent on Extra gum than on significant weight loss.

C'mon NBC. Wake up and get back on track. You don't have much time to lose. Nor much of an audience either.


(c) NBC Universal.

Related Topics:

Technorati Tags: , , ,

Posted by: Nancy Davis, Safety4Kids at 3/12/2008 05:08:00 PM

Wednesday, March 05, 2008

The Biggest Loser - Couples: All for One, One For All
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

And everyone for that vending machine!

Oh what a night. A boring, boring, boring night. This show is so far off track it's hard to know what to say anymore. Let's just say The Biggest Loser-Couples is having an identity crisis. As we've mentioned in our previous posts, this show is no longer about weight loss, exercise and achieving better health. Not that these things are not important to the contestants; they're just not important to the producers.

Yes, we went with everyone to the doctor and were impressed with the results of their hard work--they've all been "upgraded", medically, from "critical" to "fair". It is genuinely good news and very encouraging. And as we revisited their early medical appointments, we were reminded of their astounding progress. So why isn't that enough? Roger reached a milestone last night of 100 pounds lost. Dan is at 99. Not dramatic enough television?

photoInstead we watched each contestant face a vending machine filled with snack food, shameless product placement gum, and rewards including cash and "one pound pass" cards to be used at the weigh-in. If they hit the wrong combination of letters and numbers, out dropped a Twinkie and they had to eat it. Honestly, is this appropriate for a show that used to be about weight loss? The lucky ones got the shameless product placement gum and the cash. The unlucky ones ate over a thousand calories worth of trans fats. It was ridiculous.

The challenge had each contestant fly over a canyon on a zip line, pulling off flags along the way. This is where the identity crisis really took hold. Now the show is part Amazing Race, part Survivor, part Queen for a Day. Uh-oh. Showing our age. Google it if it doesn't ring a bell.

The one shining light in all of this was Bernie. Sweet, bandana-clad Bernie. Bernie and Brittany, you may remember (if you are able to stay awake for the full two hours each week), is the lone couple who began this journey as strangers. Early on we suggested that this fact could prove beneficial. And it did. They were the last couple standing intact. And they have been the two people genuinely and consistently cheering for each other and supporting each other through...well...thick and thin. So when Bernie won "Biggest Loser of the Week" last time and claimed his reward, he chose "game play" and was given the opportunity to grant immunity to any contestant on either team, just not himself. And rather than "play the game" and offer this great gift to someone in an effort to improve his own chances, he selflessly awarded the prize to Brittany, because they're partners and friends and he wanted to be sure she would live to play another week. As it turned out, in the words of Elfaba from "Wicked", "no good deed goes unpunished" and so Bernie was eliminated. And the "big twist" at the end was that there are no more teams--it's every one for themselves now. This will likely have the biggest impact on Bob's blue team of macho men, who still high-five and cheer "pride" after every workout.

We're glad this season has passed the halfway mark. We desperately hope that next season will see a return to one hour episodes focused on exercise and healthy eating, support and encouragement. In other words, we're hoping for a miracle. But hey, you gotta believe, right?

(c) NBC Universal.

Related Topics:

Technorati Tags: , , , ,

Posted by: Nancy Davis, Safety4Kids at 3/05/2008 01:16:00 PM

background